317-848-8050 Open an Account

What Happens If You Can't Deliver on a Forward Contract

If you cannot deliver, the contract does not disappear. Typically the buyer will require you to buy out the bushels at the current market price, pay a cancellation fee, or roll the obligation to a later period. If prices have risen since you signed, the buyout can be expensive. Crop insurance proceeds are often what keeps a bad year from becoming a disaster.

The Obligation Does Not Vanish with the Crop

A forward contract is a legal commitment to deliver bushels, not a commitment to try. If a drought, flood, or hail storm wipes out the acres behind the contract, you still owe the buyer. The most common resolutions are a buyout — you pay the buyer the difference between your contract price and the current market to be released — or a roll, where the obligation is pushed into the next crop year, sometimes with a fee and usually with the basis renegotiated.

Buyers are not being cruel when they enforce this. Your elevator has almost certainly hedged your contracted bushels in the futures market, and when you do not deliver, they are left holding that hedge with no grain to offset it. The buyout price is what makes them whole.

How Bad Can It Get?

The pain scales with the market move. Contract corn at $4.50 for fall delivery, lose the crop, and watch December futures run to $5.50 — you may owe roughly a dollar a bushel plus fees to walk away. On 50,000 bushels, that is a $50,000 problem with no crop to sell. In a widespread short crop, that is exactly the scenario: prices rally hardest precisely when the most producers are short bushels.

In a genuine regional disaster, many elevators will work with you — deferring delivery, settling on insurance-adjusted bushels, or rolling to next year. But that is goodwill, not a contractual right, unless your contract says otherwise.

How to Protect Yourself Before You Sign

  • Contract only bushels you are confident of. Many producers cap forward sales at or below their crop-insurance guarantee, so revenue insurance effectively funds a buyout if the crop fails.
  • Read the default and cancellation clauses. Know the fee schedule and whether acts of God change anything — usually they do not.
  • Consider hedging instead for early sales. A futures or options hedge locks in price direction with no delivery obligation. You can lift the hedge if the crop fails. Futures trading involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for all investors.
  • Spread delivery windows. Selling across multiple periods reduces the chance one weather event hits everything you owe.

Related Guides & Tools

Cash Forward Contracts: Pros and ConsForward Contracts vs Crop InsurancePrevent Plant and Your Marketing PlanCorn Futures & PricesContact a Broker

What Happens If You Can't Deliver on a Forward Contract — FAQ

Does crop insurance cover a forward contract buyout?

Revenue-protection insurance can offset much of the loss because it pays when revenue falls — including when prices rise and your yield falls short. But the indemnity is not tied to your contract, and timing is not exact. It is a cushion, not a guarantee.

Can an elevator force me to deliver in a drought year?

Yes, unless the contract has an act-of-God or force-majeure clause that covers you — most grain contracts do not. In practice many buyers negotiate deferrals or settlements in disaster years, but they are not required to.

What is the difference between a buyout and a roll?

A buyout settles the contract for cash — you pay the market difference and walk away. A roll moves your delivery obligation into a later crop year, usually at a renegotiated basis and sometimes with a service fee.

Talk It Through with a Real Broker

Call Lannie Cohen at 317-848-8050 — 40+ years of commodity experience, one phone call away.

Call 317-848-8050 Open an Account